Top Guaranteed Fixed Annuities in New York

TermInsurer / ProductRatingRate
3 years
Prosperity / SBLI USA
Select Choice (NY) 3
A- 4.45%
Prosperity / SBLI USA
Select Choice (NY) 3
A- 4.40%
Prosperity / SBLI USA
Select Choice (NY) 3
A- 4.00%
Prosperity / SBLI USA
Select Choice (NY) 3
A- 3.95%
5 years
Nassau
Nassau MYAnnuity 5 (New York)
B++ 4.95%
Nassau
Nassau MYAnnuity 5 (New York)
B++ 4.75%
Prosperity / SBLI USA
Select Choice (NY) 5
A- 4.65%
Prosperity / SBLI USA
Select Choice (NY) 5
A- 4.60%
Prosperity / SBLI USA
Select Choice (NY) 5
A- 4.25%
7 years
Prosperity / SBLI USA
Select Choice (NY) 7
A- 5.15%
Prosperity / SBLI USA
Select Choice (NY) 7
A- 5.10%
Prosperity / SBLI USA
Select Choice (NY) 7
A- 4.60%
Prosperity / SBLI USA
Select Choice (NY) 7
A- 4.55%

Ready to buy and apply for an annuity? Have questions? Click “Contact Us.”

Contact Us

Want to shop in our marketplace and research specific products?

Click “Find Your Annuity” to go to our marketplace with various filters like state, amount, term length, preference for free withdrawals, and insurer rating. Remember an annuity must be available in your home state for you to buy it.

Find Your Annuity

What Is the Best Fixed Annuity in New York?

The best fixed annuity in New York pays 5.15% compound interest, as of 2/8/26, offered on the Select Choice (NY) 7 product issued by Prosperity / SBLI USA, which carries a A- rating.

The next best fixed annuity in New York pays 5.10% compound interest, as of 2/8/26, offered on the Select Choice (NY) 7 product issued by Prosperity / SBLI USA, which carries a A- rating.

PlanEasy Inc. BBB Business Review
Sitemap

Savings

Estate

Income

Taxes

Health & Longevity

Annuites

Tools

Learning Center

About Us

Contact Us
support@planeasy.com
(402) 235-5150
PlanEasy Inc.
233 South 13th Street, Suite 1100
Lincoln, Nebraska 68508
Legal
Privacy Policy

This site and the associated materials are being provided for informational purposes only to allow consumers to make their own purchasing decisions. Representatives are available to answer specific questions you may have about a product you are considering. However, neither PlanEasy, Inc. nor its owners, officers, employees, agents, representatives or contractors (collectively "PlanEasy") provide advice or recommendations regarding the purchase of any products, nor is tax, legal, or investment advice provided. In addition, PlanEasy does not provide advice or recommendations regarding the source of funds used to purchase an annuity. Always consult with your own qualified financial, tax, and legal advisers regarding your own unique circumstances. It is important that you review and understand the product brochure created by the applicable insurance company prior to making any purchasing decisions. Annuity guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuing company. Product and feature availability may vary by state. Please ensure you review and understand all product information, features, restrictions, risks, benefits and costs before making a purchasing decision. For additional product information, please visit the specific insurance company websites directly. Consumers who purchase an annuity should thereafter contact the appropriate insurance company to have their questions answered, effect any changes to their annuity, or for any transactions involving their annuity.
© 2026 PlanEasy Inc. | All Rights Reserved